Ethics in War

Tuesday, September 27, 2005

What Is It

第二次世界大战后的纽伦堡审判以及由此产生的各种公约将战争的正确和错误方式编成了法典。战俘有明确的权利,非战斗人员应与士兵区别对待。有些人认为战争道德的概念毫无意义,在现代战争背景下,区分士兵和非战斗人员毫无意义。约翰和肯根据对与错的哲学理论来讨论这些问题。

Listening Notes

When considering war there are religious religions for avoiding and entering into war, there are prudential concerns, and there are worries about the large-scale effects on both countries and the combatants. Ken introduces the idea of Just War Theory, which is concerned with the justice of entering into war, the proper conduct in war, and justice after a war. There are also some people who hold that moral judgments cannot be passed in war, known as realists.

The guest of the show is queried by John as to how something as terrible as war can be considered a right action at any given moment. What interests and considerations allow for this? Pacifists argue that there are no conditions under which war is permissible due to the enormous amounts of damage, both physical and psychological, that it causes. The discussion traces back thousands of years, to people like Augustine and Aquinas, who asked the same questions that are asked on the show, about whether or not it can be considered permissible to enter into war. They argued that while the answer is most often no, there are considerations under which it can be allowed.

Self-defense in the case of an invasion is considered by many to be the most obvious case where war is permissible. However, our guest notes that there are some who would say that even an invasion is not grounds for retribution. Ken argues that he cannot understand this argument given the present conditions of the world, once a group performs an unjust action itself. If an utterly despicable enemy presents itself, are you justified in taking any actions during the war to win and overcome the evil, or are you just reducing yourself to that level? One of the problems discussed about war is that countries and combatants are prone to self-deception in acting for a particular cause and in performing certain actions.

  • Roving Philosophical Report(寻求第2章18节):艾米·斯坦登(Amy Standen)问,一个人是否可以同时兼具道德和杀戮训练。她拜访了纽约视觉艺术学院的一位哲学教授,这位教授本人是一名参加过越南战争的海军陆战队员。

Transcript